When someone wants to learn how to trade, where do they start? What markets should they focus on? What setups or patterns should they consider trading? How much risk should they take in their trades?
All of these are common first questions, and all of them are the wrong initial questions.
Learning how to trade begins with a conceptual framework: an understanding of how and why markets move and how and why they are related to one another.
When scientists undertake experiments, they don't throw all sorts of things at the wall to see what sticks. They begin with a theory--a tentative explanation of their observations--and then use that theory to guide the genesis and testing of hypotheses. "There is nothing so practical as a good theory," psychologist Kurt Lewin once remarked. The theory organizes thought; it helps us focus on what is important and eliminate what is irrelevant.
Psychologists operate with their theoretical, conceptual frameworks as well. The psychoanalytic perspective initially pioneered by Freud; the cognitive-behavioral approaches derived from learning research: these are ways of making sense of people and their patterns. The value of such frameworks is in their ability to help guide psychologists and their clients understand and address problems in new ways.
Too often traders begin learning markets by trying to learn patterns that they can trade. Without the scientist's grounding in observation and theory, such traders end up risking their money without truly understanding what they're doing and how it fits into the larger picture of supply and demand in their markets. No wonder these traders have difficulty sustaining confidence and discipline: if you don't grasp why you're doing something, it's hard to do it with conviction.
In these posts devoted to "An Introduction to Trading" we'll begin with a conceptual framework, so that you can understand *why* and *how* markets move. From that framework, we'll then explore practice: how to identify regions of greater and lesser opportunity. The framework that these posts will build is hardly the only perspective out there; nor is it necessarily the best for all people. Rather, it's a view that I have found quite helpful in 30+ years of trading markets and coaching traders. Your job over time is to extract what you find useful in this perspective and integrate it with your own observations and ideas.
When journeying to a new destination, it helps to have a map. A conceptual framework is a mental map: a view of the trader's territory. Don't be so quick to get to the destination that you trade without understanding and leave yourself confused and frustrated. Markets will always be there; opportunity changes, but never goes away. Now is the time to build your map and chart your course. Let's begin that process with the next post.
RELATED POST:
Resources for Learning How to Trade
.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


7 comments:
Over the years, I've written quite a lot about using publicly available academic and IB research to build retail trading systems.
It seems to me that if your conceptual framework is based on a review of 50+ years of research, it's probably a good starting point for getting active in the markets.
It also seems to me that the problem most wannabe traders have is more one of conflicted motives - they don't want to make money in the markets through the easiest possible ways, they want the romance and excitement of T-R-A-D-I-N-G along with the fantasy of financial freedom through it; thus, building a conceptual framework is a secondary concern to "getting started trading."
I discovered you a few day ago but I like you because you said just now
"an understanding of how and why markets move and how and why they are related to one another."
I was difficult for me to begin to find document that could introduce me at your sentence. Only the old book of Douglass Taylor told me many things and a method to investigate the market. The street is very long and at the moment I am asking to myself the following things:
1) Where does market maker operate from?
2) Where does insider operate from?
3) Which relation is there between them if there?
Perhaps I am asking useless things but until I have a response every thing is important. So if you could suggest to me some books also of yours thank you. Exscuse for my English
Dr. Steenbarger,
This couldn't have begun better. I am looking forward for the whole process.
Best trading,
Jorge
Hi Brett
Nice posting. I am looking forward to your followup article on frameworks.
In terms of such frameworks have always found it useful to thing about two old chestnuts:
a) Are the markets too random to trade profitably
b) are the markets too efficient to trade profitably
in exploring why the answer is no to both questions it has helped me improve my trading
Hi brett
Thanks so much for the amazing post. I am looking forward to your next post.
Thanks so much for taking the time to help all the beginners like me.
Thanks
"Your job over time is to extract what you find useful in this perspective and integrate it with your own observations and ideas."
Perfect. Too many readers take too much of what they read as gospel. You are telling readers to think for themselves.
Way to go, Dr. B!
Thanks for the valuable comments and the kind support for this project. Bill, good point about the importance of using historical research to build trading systems. Whether discretionary or systems trading, there's no escaping the hard work and preparation needed for success.
Alessandro, I do intend to broaden the discussion to include considerations of *who* is participating in the markets--a very important consideration, especially for short time frame traders.
And thanks much for your support, Jorge--
Brett
Post a Comment