We made a three day high on the Dow on Wednesday with a VIX reading below 12. So I decided to investigate what happens three days later.
Since March, 2003 (N = 792 trading days), when the Dow has made a three-day high and the VIX has been 12 or higher (N = 268), the next three days in the Dow have averaged a gain of .22% (163 up, 105 down).
When the Dow has made a three-day high and the VIX has been under 12 (N = 69), the next three days in the Dow have averaged a loss of -.03% (37 up, 32 down).
Once again, we see that a low VIX is associated with subnormal short-term returns.