Saturday, March 15, 2008
Formatting Your Trading Journal for Success
The reason I'm offering the suggestion is that I continue to find that traders use journals in ways that are less than constructive. The greatest mistakes in journaling, I find, are:
1) Lack of Specifics - The journal contains vague, general intentions such as, "I need to trade less aggressively", without any indication of how the trader will accomplish this. If the intent is to trade less aggressively, then the journal should create a specific goal. An example from my own trading would be: "I'll enter positions with one unit and scale in with a second unit on the first pullback in NYSE TICK when my position is profitable." Notice how this makes the general intention so much more concrete. Now I have something constructive to implement and can grade myself on the implementation. If I only say, "I need to trade less aggressively", that's not goal-setting. That's Monday-morning quarterbacking, or me just wagging my finger at myself. Self-criticism by itself never improved anyone: it's self-criticism followed by constructive problem solving that does the trick.
2) Focus on Negatives - The worst journals are the ones that simply vent fear or frustration. They recite every bad or missed trade, everything that went wrong during the day. Not only is there an absence of constructive suggestions for improvement, but there is also an absence of ideas re: what the trader has done right. The idea is to learn from what you do right, not just what you do wrong. Indeed, focusing on strengths will enhance motivation and the sense of competence and efficacy. By staying exclusively problem-focused, it's all too easy to drain motivation and optimism.
So, how can we improve the above in a format for a trading journal?
My suggestion is starting the journal with a listing of your specific goal(s) for that trading day.
Those goals should be: a) chosen from your previous day's or week's trading; and b) taken from your trading rules. The goal should be either to improve a mistake you made, or to build upon something you did right. The goal should state specifically what you expect yourself to do during the coming day, so that you can rehearse the goal in your mind before the market opens and so that you can evaluate how you performed on the goal at the end of the day.
Notice that, before creating the journal, it's important to write out your trading rules in advance: everything that you want to follow to trade well. You can't hold yourself accountable for a rule that you don't create; that's perfectionism, and it's not helpful either. Rules should clearly state how you want to size positions, enter them, exit them, set stops, set exits, scale in and out of trades, etc. Your journal will track how well you follow these rules, not just whether you make money or not.
So you start with rules, notice when you do a particularly good or poor job following the rules, and then set goals for the next day based on the good or poor performance. The journal entry then gives yourself a grade at the end of the day for how well you performed on your goals and why you earned that grade. Include your daily P/L with your grade, so that you can quickly see how your performance rises and falls with your grades.
The journal keeps you constructive, keeps you learning, and keeps you working on the things that are most important. It is not a tool for simply rehashing the day or voicing your feelings; it is your tool for self-development: your means for coaching yourself.
RELEVANT POST:
When Coaching Works and Doesn't Work
.
Friday, March 14, 2008
Using Trading Journals to Identify and Change Your Patterns
1) Patterns of Negative Self-Talk: These occur during frustrated moments in markets. We miss a trade, a trade blows through our stop, we give back our money on the day: all of these create frustration. This frustration then triggers an anger response that we direct toward ourselves. For example, we might find ourself saying, "Here it goes again! Other people are killing these markets, and I can't get it going." At that point, your frustration is no longer about the specific trade or market event, but is directed to *you as a person*. Trading should be about trading; not about you. After all, you wouldn't be boasting and crowing in the journal if the trade went your way. If you wouldn't like to hear your message coming from someone else (imagine your buddy at the workstation next to yours saying, "Whoa, dude, other people are killing these markets, and you can't get it going!") and if you wouldn't be speaking that way to your trading buddy, then you shouldn't be speaking that way to yourself. Interrupting that negative self-talk and turning your frustration toward a constructive kick in the pants ("C'mon, Brett, you know you shouldn't be trading so large in the chopfest. Let's stick with the rules!") can be very helpful in preventing frustration from snowballing.
2) Patterns of Impulsivity - Out of excitement, boredom, desire to regain profits, or overconfidence, you find yourself trading too frequently or with too much size. This, in turn, leads to uneven performance and outsized trading losses, which then produce discouragement. Many traders keep their goals--and their trading rules--taped to their screens; this helps keep them in the forebrain as a check on impulsivity. One trader I worked with actually had a brief checklist that he had to check off before placing any trade. This prevented him from acting hastily. If you can figure out the triggers that make you impulsive (sometimes these are winning trades, where you start playing with "house money"), you have a good chance to put on the brakes before you act on impulse.
3) Patterns of Fear - Particularly after losses, but sometimes after making money and being afraid of losing it, traders fail to act on good signals or do not size their trades adequately. The result is missed opportunity. Often this occurs if the trader is engaging in "catastrophizing": making a normal potential loss into something much larger. Worry, physical tension, and feelings of nervousness are great clues to track in a journal. Once you recognize your fear patterns, you can take some deep breaths, calm yourself, and focus on assessing opportunity (and focus on those trading rules). One way of breaking overwhelming fear after large losses is just to put on some small trades when your signals are good and get your rhythm and confidence back. Then you ramp back up to normal size in a gradual, but steady manner. Playing defense is not giving into fear: having rules about risk control and hanging onto a day's profits can help you distinguish the two.
Once you notice your patterns, it's easier to construct specific goals for the next day's and week's trade. The overarching goal is changing your patterns: controlling how you think and feel rather than having them control you. It's difficult to imagine changing your patterns if you're not aware of them in the first place!
RELEVANT POSTS:
Using Emotion to Change Emotion
Some 2007 Posts on Trading and Emotions
.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
Using Trading Journals to Improve Trading Performance
We know from research in psychology that goal-settting is an effective tool for performance development. Goals should be:
1) Challenging, but attainable;
2) Limited in number
3) Accompanied by regular feedback to cement learning and tailor new goals.
A journal format that I like translates each goal into a "subject" in a "report card". For frequent traders (i.e., those who trade intraday and/or every day), a single grade at the end of the day (A, B, C, D, F) indicates the degree to which the goal was met that day. Beside each grade go comments and observations that explain why the grade was given. Ideally, these comments should include what was happening in markets (and trading) at the time; what was going on in terms of the trader's thoughts and feelings; and what the trading outcomes were.
An advantage of this format is that it places equal emphasis upon the identification and assessment of strengths (the "A" grades) as weaknesses (the "F" grades). It focuses traders on the most relevant areas for improvement and easily leads to new goal setting for the following day when a poor grade is received in a particular area.
Traders I work with email me the journal/report cards daily and I provide daily email feedback. We then "meet" weekly by phone to review the week, learn from recent efforts, and set overarching goals for the next week. By utilizing the online medium for coaching, we minimize time and expense and achieve much of the advantages of having a full-time personal coach.
This regularity of contact is especially useful in ensuring that problem patterns are identified quickly and do not snowball. The money saved in drawdowns as a result is significant. The report cards are also helpful in focusing traders on their strengths, so that they can take maximum advantage of what they're doing right.
I use a variation of this report card format myself and have found it helpful for my own development as a trader. The key to using it for oneself is setting regular time aside to review the card, identify specific goals and actions for improvement, and then tracking those efforts at change the next day--repeating this process through the week. My experience is that one can achieve a compounding of learning with such active review.
It's also possible to connect with peers for mutual mentoring by sharing online journals/report cards. This is one of the advantages of such social networking platforms for traders as Stocktickr. Like going to the gym with a buddy to keep each other focused and motivated, collaborating on journals can be a great way to build advantages of a trading group even when trading independently.
RELEVANT POSTS:
Trader Perspectives on Keeping a Journal
Turning Setbacks Into Goals
.
Wednesday, March 12, 2008
Tracking the NYSE TICK and Other Wednesday Thoughts


Tracking the TICK: Several traders have emailed and asked about easy ways to track the distribution of the NYSE TICK, which (as I mentioned yesterday) caught the afternoon rally quite nicely. One simple method (top chart) is to create a moving average of the TICK (mine is a ten-period average of five-minute bars) and then track: a) whether the average is dominantly above or below the zero (black) line; and b) whether the average is upwardly, downwardly, or non-sloping. We can see how the blue TICK MA line stayed positive (and upward sloping) for most the afternoon.
Double Bottom?: The Banking Index ($BKX; bottom chart), for all the woes of the financial sector, could not make new lows during the recent market weakness, creating a nice double bottom pattern. We're now rallying very sharply off that bottom. Headlines feature scary bank news, but markets are forward-looking and may be indicating a degree of stabilization. The key will be the ability of some of these troubled investment banks and broker/dealers to hold their recent lows.
The Next Bubble? - Check out links from Abnormal Returns, especially re: how the next bubble has to be large enough to rescue us from this one. Also note the post on generating superior returns by pursuing hot anomalies in markets.
Brief Observation - When people heatedly challenge your views on markets, but offer no evidence or analytical reasoning to back their arguments, you know that theirs is a defensive reaction. At some level they know they're wrong, and they're feeling threatened. It's one of the best market tells I've found, which is why I never discourage nasty emails and blog comments.
.
How Much Coaching is Enough: A Look at the Dose-Effect Relationship in Counseling and Psychotherapy
This similarity suggests that issues that have long interested counselors and psychotherapists are relevant to coaches. One of these is the dose-effect relationship: how much coaching is needed on average to achieve a particular change? Fortunately there is a rich research literature in this area that is relevant to coaches and those who purchase their services. In this and subsequent posts, I will explore the implications of this research.
My review of this literature back in 1994 found that the dose-effect relationship in the helping fields is a function of many different factors, including the following:
* Severity, Duration, and Complexity of Presenting Problems - On average, it takes longer to achieve a given level of benefit for people with severe problems (those that greatly impair functioning), chronic problems (those with longstanding concerns), and complex problems (those that manifest themselves in multiple, interacting ways).
* Nature of the Changes Sought - On average, changes in mood and attitude are achieved earlier than changes in actual functioning. With good coaching, for instance, a trader will start to feel better about his work before he actually starts to trade and perform better.
* Motivation and Involvement of the Person Being Helped - On average, those who are more motivated for change and who are more highly involved in the helping process achieve gains more quickly than those who are ambivalent about change or who are less engaged in change efforts.
* Readiness for Change - On average, those who clearly identify specific changes they wish to make and are ready to take action on those benefit from assistance more rapidly than those who need time to explore their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors and come to greater self-understanding prior to formulating targeted goals.
* Duration of Changes Sought - On average, changes can be initiated in a relatively brief time span, but it takes a greater dose of helping to achieve changes that will be longstanding. This is because of the phenomenon of relapse: if helping is too brief, changes aren't truly internalized and the risk of relapse increases significantly.
Research by Kenneth Howard and colleagues conducted in the mid-1980s--and later replicated by a variety of investigators--found that about half of all people seeking assistance in therapy achieve their gains within eight sessions. Once again, these favorable short-term outcomes were more common among those with less severe and less chronic problems than among those with pervasive and longstanding concerns. Indeed, when we look just at people with relatively mild and recent presenting complaints, the number achieving significant change within eight sessions soars to 75%. It is precisely for this reason that we should expect coaching to be an ideal medium for brief change, as coaching is explicitly aimed at non-clinical populations.
What this research suggests is that, if coaching is truly appropriate for an individual, it should be able to proceed in a relatively brief manner to achieve targeted changes. Long-term coaching may be as much an indication of practitioner shortcomings (or client dependency) as practical necessity.
One variable not commonly addressed in this research is the competence of the person providing helping services. An interesting recent study conducted at a training clinic (and therefore utilizing less experienced helpers) found an attenuated dose-effect curve overall: it took more sessions to achieve a given level of average benefit. An earlier investigation at a training clinic found that only 22% of clients achieved significant gains after 8 sessions, compared to the 50% reported in the literature. The first study also found reliable differences among helpers: some just seemed to yield better outcomes than others. It may well be that training and experience (as well as helping skill) enable helpers to more quickly establish good working relationships with others; target problem areas; and introduce methods for addressing these areas.
This is an important research finding, given the lack of substantive credentialing and experience among many who hold themselves out as coaches. With coaches as with traders, skill and experience appear to make a significant difference in generating outcomes.
RELATED POST:
Coaching the Professional Trader
.
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Stock Market Divergences and Other Pattern Recognition Themes for Tuesday


* Catching Divergences - I've recently been posting on the topic of market themes and divergence patterns. Today's trade provided a great example. Note the double bottom in the ES futures (top chart, blue arrow), as the index made a marginal new price low for the regular trading session. The NYSE TICK (bottom chart, blue arrow), however, showed distinctly less selling at the fresh price low. Indeed, that second low in ES was not confirmed by price lows in the Russell futures, the banking stocks ($BKX), or the Dow Industrials (DIA). Once the market rebounded from the divergence, the TICK began a positive shift in distribution (note the rising blue moving average line in the second chart), which helped keep traders on the right side of the market, participating in the major bear *pwnage. (Note: it's really the same pattern--just at a larger time scale--that I noted in the recent post on the bear market).
* Preparing for the Rally - Check out this great post from Charles Kirk, particularly the good questions to ask about the positions you're holding.
* Rally or Just Short Covering? - Trader Mike notes the Fed catalyst and asks the important question as to whether the initial short covering could attract the participation of bulls. The ability of the market to catch a second wind after the initial rally led to profit taking was a positive sign for bulls.
* Identifying Your Own Patterns - When you know your own patterns as a trader, you're more able to catch and modify them. Check out this excellent post from Ray Barros on "the power of questions" to identify our patterns.
* More Pattern Recognition - Check out the chart-based pattern recognition post on the Afraid to Trade blog that captured the day's action. And, for a different pattern that has worked exceedingly well, check out Kevin's post on the yen's relationship to the stock market.
* Questioning a Pattern - The Quantifiable Edges blog takes a historical look at divergence patterns in the new high/low data.
* An Online Newspaper - The Newsflashr site that I linked in a recent post was just featured in an article in the Boston Globe. Very useful service, IMO, for catching patterns in global news.
.
An Oversold Stock Market Amidst a Crisis of Confidence

We've hit oversold levels (below -30) in my Adjusted Demand/Supply Index; as mentioned earlier, these levels have been associated with favorable returns 20 days out and overbought readings (above +20) have provided a nice heads-up for subnormal returns over that span. I generally act on these readings when we see a pattern of waning new highs in an overbought market and dwindling new lows in an oversold one. The new high/new low picture was mixed on Monday, with 20-day new lows across the NYSE, NASDAQ, and ASE exceeding the Friday level (223 new highs and 3318 new lows on Monday vs. 224 highs and 3150 lows on Friday), but 52-week new lows among NYSE common stocks, SPX stocks, and NDX stocks dropping from Friday to Monday.
Meanwhile, the crisis of confidence among financial issues continued unabated on Monday, which is one of those themes I've been tracking for overall market direction. The Cumulative NYSE TICK, which has been dreadfully weak of late, continued so on Monday--another useful gauge of daily market direction--no doubt reflecting sentiment among traders, who are seeing daily new lows among such stocks as GS, FNM, C, BSC, and MER. A look at the longer-term charts of these issues is truly harrowing: FNM has gone from about 70 in August, 2007 to under 20 on Monday; MER has been cut in half since June; and C has gone from 54 to under 20 in that same time period. Moreover, the rate of damage has been accelerating: C has moved from 26 to under 20 within the last two weeks; FNM has gone from about 30 to under 20; and MER has moved from 55 to 43 in that same span.
Nor has weakness been limited to financial shares. Among the 40 stocks in my basket (equally divided among 8 sectors from the S&P 500 Index), my measure of Technical Strength (short-term trending) is also at highly oversold levels that have typified recent intermediate-term market lows. Two of the stocks qualify as trading in uptrends, five are neutral, and 33 are in downtrends. The overall Technical Strength Index, at -2160, is near levels reached at the January market lows.
As the recent post emphasized, the selling extremes we've been seeing (such as those 3318 new 20-day lows) are consistent with a momentum low in the stock market (which tends to precede price lows), but to enjoy more than a bullish bout of short covering, we need to see confidence enter the financial sector and buying sentiment return to stocks overall (an upward sloping Cumulative NYSE TICK). I'll continue to watch those two tells for day-to-day market direction, even as I stay alert for evidence of dwindling new lows at these oversold levels and a potential market rebound.
.
Monday, March 10, 2008
Why Financial Crises Are Inevitable
"Banks and hedge funds are in control of a ridiculous amount of the world’s wealth. They also trade irresponsibly large quantities of complex derivatives. They slavishly and unimaginatively copy each other, all holding similar positions. These contracts are then dynamically hedged by buying and selling shares according to mathematical formulae. This can and does exacerbate the volatility of the underlying."
He also points out that too much money will always chase too few products because large, undiversified bets with other people's money will always provide the most tempting returns for money managers.
In this vein, I highly recommend Richard Bookstaber's text "A Demon of Our Own Design: Markets, Hedge Funds, and the Perils of Financial Innovation" (Wiley, 2007). In his concluding chapter, entitled "Built to Crash?", he observes:
"...the positive effects of innovation come a a price. Innovation increases complexity. Many innovative instruments are in the form of derivatives with conditional and nonlinear payoffs. When a market dislocation arises, it is difficult to know how the prices of these instruments will react. Innovation and mechanical efficiency have also increased complexity by pushing markets to become more interconnected...The combination of tight coupling and complexity is a formula for normal accidents--accidents that are all but inevitable as a result of the structure of the system." (p. 255-256).
This line of reasoning has powerful implications for risk management. We tend to think of risk in terms of standard deviations and normal distributions. Financial systems, however, possess fat tails of returns--and increasing complexity may only increase this "fatness". We can calculate the historical odds of a market crash, but will such models accurately capture risk in systems of increasingly tight coupling?
Paul Wilmott concludes:
Banks and hedge funds employ mathematicians with no financial-market experience to build models that no one is testing scientifically for use in situations where they were not intended by traders who don’t understand them. And people are surprised by the losses!
If sophisticated mathematical models can't capture risk and complexity, can we expect the gut hunches of discretionary traders to do better? There's a lesson in all this, and it seems to be: The odds of catastrophic financial outcomes are greater than we estimate. Even when we think we're diversified, the tight coupling of complex, interwoven financial systems ensures that, at times of stress, correlations will tend toward one or minus-one.
Looking for more reading on complexity and how we are "fooled by randomness"? Check out Nassim Taleb's website and this excellent summary of his ideas. They provide a sobering perspective on how we don't really know what we don't know.
Indicator Update for March 10th
* New Highs/Lows - Friday we saw levels of new lows consistent with recent momentum lows in markets. There were 224 new 20-day highs against 3150 new lows. We also saw 97 new 65-day highs across the NYSE, NASDAQ, and ASE, against 1225 new lows. This represents significant weakness, but so far remains below the level of new lows registered in January. Similarly, if we just look at the common stocks traded on the NYSE, we had 7 new 52-week highs, but 246 new lows. Note that 52-week new lows in January swelled to over 700. Among S&P 600 small caps, Friday had 2 new 52-week highs and 80 new lows. (January's new lows exceeded 200). And finally, among the S&P 500 large caps, we had no new highs and 73 fresh annual lows. (January's new lows also exceeded 200). Long story short, there are divergences in the high/low data that make me question the downside from here.
* Sentiment - As my recent post indicated, sentiment is quite bearish and is beginning to hit levels associated with recent market bottoms. Shorter-term, we continue to see weakness in the NYSE TICK, with the cumulative line in a clear downtrend. I need to see evidence of buying interest in the TICK before aggressively pursuing the upside in this market. Seven of the last eight trading sessions have seen net selling in the Cumulative Adjusted TICK; my breakdown of buying vs. selling interest shows overwhelmingly above average selling pressure during that time. The coast is not clear for bulls unless and until this selling pressure abates and we see evidence of above-average buying (which has occurred only once in the past eight sessions).
* Overbought/Oversold - My Cumulative Demand/Supply indicator is a hair breadth away from the -30 level that has typified recent bottoms in the stock market. Supply has exceeded demand for six of the past seven trading sessions, which shows unusual sustained selling activity. (Recall that Supply and Demand are indexes of the number of stocks closing below vs. above the volatility envelopes surrounding their moving averages). Longer-term, we have 18% of SPX stocks trading above their 200-day moving averages and 14% trading above their 50-day moving averages--quite oversold, but still above the very low levels registered in January(14% and 8%, respectively).
* Advance-Decline Lines - We're seeing new lows in the AD Lines for NYSE common stocks and for NASDAQ 100 stocks, S&P 500 stocks, and S&P 600 stocks. It is clearly premature to be aggressively buying the market while this indicator remains in a downtrend across the board.
In sum, we're seeing levels in the indicators consistent with momentum market lows. Price lows can occur beneath such momentum lows, so it is not at all inconceivable that we could see more downside in the days to come. Indeed, recent activity has been skewed solidly to the downside, making bottom-fishing dangerous. Still, for the first time in this bear market, we're seeing divergences in the data even amidst the selling pressure and bearish sentiment. That has me questioning the longer-term viability of the downside.
.
Sunday, March 09, 2008
Stock Market Sentiment: What the Relative Equity Put/Call Ratio is Telling Us

As the chart above indicates, rises in the relative equity put/call ratio (which I operationalize as the 10-day equity put/call volume ratio divided by the 200-day ratio) have been reliably associated with market bottoms since 2004. On Friday, we saw the 10-day ratio exceed the 200-day ratio by over 20%.
Since 2004 (N = 1033 trading days), we've had 129 occasions in which the relative put/call ratio has met or exceeded the 20% threshold. Twenty days later, the S&P 500 Index (SPY) has been up by an average of 2.22% (103 up, 26 down), much stronger than the average 20-day gain of .11% (537 up, 367 down) for the remainder of the sample.
More broadly, when the relative equity put/call ratio has been above 1.0 (meaning that we're seeing more puts traded relative to calls over the past 10 days compared to the past 200 days), the next 20 trading days in SPY have averaged a gain of .84%. When the relative ratio has been below 1.0, the next 20 days in SPY have averaged a loss of -.31%.
While it is certainly possible for the market to get weaker in the short run even when the ratio has exceeded 1.20 (50 of the 129 occasions were down after five trading days), it's generally paid to fade extremes in the relative equity put/call ratio.
RELATED POSTS:
What We Can Learn From the Equity Put/Call Ratio
What to Expect When Equity Options Traders are Bearish
.
More Insight Into How to Lose at Trading
Let's take a different approach to the issue. Suppose I want to make sure that a rising market is truly in an uptrend and not just making a random bounce. Similarly, I want to ensure that a downtrend is significant before I jump on board. So I construct an indicator that will tell me when a move is significant vs. random.
Specifically, I take a 20-day moving average of the S&P 500 Index (SPY) and calculate Bollinger Bands (a volatility envelope) above and below the average. The bands are set for two standard deviations of price movement. Thus, if the market closes above the upper band, that means that it has made a statistically significant move above its average. If it closes below the band, that means that the market has moved significantly below its average.
The strategy is to not assume a trend is in place until the market has moved significantly--not just randomly--in a directional fashion.
So how does such a strategy fare? Let's update a post from last May.
Over the last three years, buying closes above the 20-day bands and selling closes below the bands has given us 14 winning trades and 29 losers in SPY for a net loss of 20 points (the equivalent of 200 S&P cash or futures points). The average gain for winning trades was .48 point in SPY. The average size of losers was .31 point. The setup captures larger winners than losers on average, but cannot make money because there are so many more losing trades than winners.
Of the 43 trades, 25 were long and 18 were short. Among the long trades, there were 11 winners and 14 losers. Of the 18 short trades, only 3 were winners and 15 were losers.
The superior performance on long trades suggests that, when this setup works, it captures the longer-term trend in the market. Interestingly in this regard, all three winning short trades have occurred since July of 2007, which is when the current bear market began. When the setup trades against the market's longer-term trend, the results are abysmal.
So what does this tell us? If we wait for a trend to become "significant" and obvious, it is too late. There is no systematic edge chasing a move that has already closed outside a volatility envelope. Indeed, to repeat a conclusion from my earlier post, pursuing a countertrend move outside the envelope has such a poor track record that it is promising.
The best way to lose at trading is to go with the obvious. I've argued in the past that the market is rigged against human nature: it is easy to lose money buying in an uptrend, and it is easy to lose money buying strength and selling weakness. Success comes to traders only when they overcome normal human biases.
.
Saturday, March 08, 2008
Weekend Links: Volume Two
* A Test of Technical Analysis - CXO Advisory reports on a study of over 7800 technical analysis rules applied to long-term Dow Jones Industrial Average data and finds room for skepticism.
* Where Jobs Are Being Lost - Calculated Risk looks at the data and the toll being taken by the housing slowdown.
* What If the Fed *Doesn't* Go 75 bps? - Econobrowser looks at implications for commodities.
* Finding Yield - Retail investors are jumping into municipal bonds, attracted by yields favorable compared with taxables, according to Accrued Interest.
* It's Who You Know That Counts - Research Recap reports on a very surprising predictor of analyst accuracy with stock recommendations.
* Next We'll Get Rid of Bars on Charts - StockTickr finds an unusual aid to trading that makes a good amount of psychological sense.
.
Friday, March 07, 2008
Trading by Patterns and Themes



We had a great setup this afternoon that followed the post on themes quite nicely. We saw weakness in the morning, a sharp rally, then a new low in the ES futures (top chart) that was not confirmed by the Russell 2000 Index (middle chart) or by the NYSE advancing minus declining stocks (bottom chart). It's those moves to new lows that can't attract the broad participation of the market that are most likely to reverse, generating a move to at least the midpoint of the day's range. That's been especially true of moves that cannot attract the participation of the financial stocks, which have been a particular bellwether of late. Like the Russells, the financial sector (XLF) and bank stocks ($BKX) held above their morning lows on the afternoon decline.
.
Friday Trading Links - Volume One
* Preparation for the Trading Day - Meanwhile, in case you haven't noticed, Mike posts both swing trade candidates and daily stock names for his watchlist; very useful for active traders. Here's a link to his swing trading rules. Charles Kirk also features a pre-opening list of gainers and losers, with chart links. (Note the wide range of topics Kirk is addressing with members of his site; looks great). More preparation for the day is offered by Alpha Trends, which summarizes technical themes and trading ideas in a useful video format. Excellent resources.
* Peer Effects - Very interesting idea from Abnormal Returns that pertains to trading firms as well as blogs: excellence among peers make us better. Check out the recent links at Abnormal Returns, including posts on worrisome credit spreads.
* Weakening Trend - The Big Picture charts the weakening jobs picture and the troubling picture with home equity.
* Best of Chris - Chris Perruna links his top 20 posts: good weekend reading here.
* Fascinating Indicator - VIX and More tracks the SPX:VIX ratio and finds a possible turn in the tide.
.
Potential Fissures in the Bear Market Foundation
Thursday we saw 317 new 20-day highs and 2268 new lows across the NYSE, NASDAQ, and ASE. A little further out, we have 128 new 65-day highs against 914 lows. Compare this with the 3943 new 65-day lows at the January lows, and you can see that most stocks have not exceeded those lows. Going still further out and looking only at common stocks that trade on the NYSE, we see that, on Thursday, we had 13 new 52-week highs and 181 new lows. That is the highest level of new lows since the January bottom, but note that at that prior bottom we had 700 new lows among NYSE common issues. Indeed, we're seeing many fewer new lows now than January across all major exchanges and indexes.
Meanwhile, we're getting oversold. Among S&P 500 stocks, we are again seeing less than 20% of stocks trading above their 50-day moving averages, which has marked recent intermediate-term lows. Interestingly, we're seeing 22% of SPX stocks trading above their 200-day moving average, which is above the 14% level seen in January--another potential divergence.
On the bearish side, we're seeing new Advance-Decline lows for NYSE common stocks and S&P 600 small caps, but not yet for SPX stocks.
To be sure, stocks are still weak; they could get weaker and still maintain these divergences. My Demand figure closed at 20 on Thursday, with Supply at 139. That means 7 times more stocks are trading below the volatility envelopes surrounding their moving averages as trading above them. Still, my Cumulative Demand/Supply indicator, which has done a superlative job of tracking intermediate-term highs and lows in recent months, is nearing a buy signal at -23.
All in all it's prudent to wait for signs of growing strength in the indicators before making major commitments to the upside. And I'll want to see some indications of confidence in financial stocks and credit markets before putting considerable risk on the long side.
But make no mistake about it: the bearishness is thick. We've had put volume exceeding call volume for equities for five consecutive sessions. The traffic on my website has once again swelled, as at the March, August, and January lows. Back in July, when stock indexes were near their highs, the indicators were showing cracks in the bull market foundation. Now we're seeing potential fissures on the bear side. That has me still quite cautious, but ready to pounce if and when the bears are forced to cover their quite exposed backsides.
.
Thursday, March 06, 2008
Insights Into Human Greatness
Colin Wilson
Dreaming to Some Purpose
p. 17
“Without struggle, no progress and no result. Every breaking of habit produces a change in the machine.”
"The evolution of man is the evolution of his consciousness, and "consciousness" cannot evolve unconsciously. The evolution of man is the evolution of his will, and "will" cannot evolve involuntarily. The evolution of man is the evolution of his power of doing, and "doing" cannot be the result of things which "happen."
G. I. Gurdjieff
"Divide in yourself the mechanical from the conscious, see how little there is of the conscious, how seldom it works, and how strong is the mechanical - mechanical attitudes, mechanical intentions, mechanical thoughts, mechanical desires."
P. D. Ouspensky
“We fear to know the fearsome and unsavory aspects of ourselves, but we fear even more to know the godlike in ourselves”
Abraham Maslow
"Anyone who fights for the future lives in it today."
“Achievement of your happiness is the only moral purpose of your life, and that happiness, not pain or mindless self-indulgence, is the proof of your moral integrity, since it is the proof and the result of your loyalty to the achievement of your values.”
Ayn Rand
Four Ways to Find Themes in the Stock Market
1) Make News Part of Your Daily Preparation - I cannot emphasize this highly enough: if you know what large market participants are tracking, you can anticipate their behavior. This means following the news that they follow. Many times breaking news stories can be useful in identifying themes early. For instance, I quickly picked up on U.S. jawboning of OPEC and tensions between Venezuela and Columbia as items that could affect the oil markets (and therefore that stock sector). There's a reason portfolio managers keep a Bloomberg news ticker on their screens, even though they are not necessarily frequent traders: they want to catch trends and ideas as those unfold. I like the Bloomberg web site, which categorizes stories by region and asset class. A particularly useful application is the Newsflashr site, which taps directly into the world's major news feeds and automatically updates and sorts news as it is disseminated. The news feeds are truly global, and a handy "cloud" at the side of the page helps you find hot news topics. I just clicked on the "business" section of the site and, scrolling down the page, found the five top themes in the recent news, along with links that are accompanied by Alexa ratings for those news sources (if you want to focus on the most popular news outlets). Over time, you can see how these news themes shift, giving you a feel for what might be influencing portfolio managers.
2) Track Market Commentary - The blogosphere is especially useful as a way of taking the pulse of market opinion. Here the key is to focus on the most credible bloggers who themselves possess market expertise and/or manage money. Many of these well-informed sources can be found via the Seeking Alpha site, which regularly updates its content. Especially useful is the categorization of Seeking Alpha posts by region (U.S. markets, Global) and market (ETFs, Sectors). This makes it easy to scan posts on particular topics and look for your favorite commentators. Alternatively, you can track the Seeking Alpha page specific to each commentator and bookmark their contributions (here's my page, for example). Want to catch commentary from traders themselves? The Instant Bull site (from the creators of Newsflashr) pulls posts from market message boards and categorizes by topic, so that you can get a feel for trader "buzz". This is especially helpful when tracking themes relevant to specific stock names. Although it's subjective, I find that tracking commentary overall can be a useful contrary indicator: when the buzz on a theme becomes too dominant, we're often ready for a near-term reversal.
3) Track Markets and Asset Classes Other Than Your Own - My trading screen typically tracks the NQ, ER2, and ES futures on a one-minute basis, so that I can see if small cap and NASDAQ stocks are confirming moves in my primary market (the S&P 500 Index). As my earlier post emphasized, I also keep an eye on 5-minute charts of the various S&P 500 sectors, so that I can identify divergences that emerge during the day session. I also periodically look at charts of asset classes that affect the stock market, including currencies (yen is a favorite), interest rates (yield curve as well as rates for specific Treasury instruments), and commodities (oil, gold). Many times, these intermarket relationships provide overall clues as to whether market participants are mostly risk-seeking or risk-averse, which typically translates into bullishness or bearishness regarding stocks. I also like to track international markets--particularly during pre-opening hours--to get a feel for how markets are processing global news. It's important to have a data provider that can give you global market information on a real-time basis. Very often, you'll see a shift in a correlated market or sector (e.g., interest rates, yen, financial stocks) seconds before a corresponding shift occurs in the stock indexes. Those are useful "tells" for the short-term trader.
4) Track Economic Indicators and Expectations - You'd be surprised how many active traders don't know the economic news reports scheduled for the day or their significance. They blithely trade in the morning, only to get "run over" when a news reaction creates a violent short-term movement. Many traders listen to the financial news channels on TV simply to hear breaking economic reports; websites such as Briefing.com and Bloomberg are also useful in identifying which reports are scheduled during the day and what the expectations are. Very many times, you can identify when the stock market is in a trending mode vs. a range mode simply by observing how stocks (as well as interest rates and currencies) behave once an economic report comes out. If the report cannot move rates or currencies out of trading ranges, it's much more likely that any initial reaction in stocks will be reversed. The same is true for Fed announcements. Knowing ranges in the major asset classes and seeing how markets behave relative to those ranges when economic news hits is one of the most useful theme-builders for morning trading in the U.S., I find.
In my Twitter posts, I try to identify major themes affecting markets and provide a heads up for economic reports, as well as market indicators. Every trader, however, depending on market and time frame, has to find user-friendly ways of detecting market themes of greatest relevance. Many, many traders grow frustrated and trade poorly because they don't see market moves coming. They are so busy watching their market that they don't see the themes shifting around them. In trading it helps to have binoculars as well as a microscope. The big moves are dictated by the big picture, and that picture is always changing.
RELEVANT POST:
Why Your Trading Isn't Working Out
.
Wednesday, March 05, 2008
Cross-Talk: Once You Own It, It Owns You
Once the audience members owned the pens and considered them their own, they systematically overvalued the pens' worth. Similarly, once we take a position in the market, it becomes *our* position and we value it simply because we have made it our own. That makes it extremely difficult to take a loss on our position, even when that is what our trading plans call for.
It's a bit like houses in the current weak housing market: many owners are unwilling to reduce the selling prices of their properties because they value their homes too much. Once we own the asset, it can own us by coloring our perceptions and actions.
I've noticed over the years that, when I'm trading well, my eye is on the stop-loss points for my positions, not on the potential price targets and profits. Explicitly spelling out how much I'm willing to lose on an idea and then staying focused on that scenario forces me to accept the possibility of loss, rather than fight it. It is a psychological trick that keeps me from getting married to my idea. By the time I put the position on, I'm already mentally prepared for it to fail.
That might sound like twisted logic to some: how can you feel confident about trading if your focus is on losing? But confidence doesn't simply come from winning; it comes from knowing that you can handle losing. By embracing the possibility of loss, we make sure that when we own a position, it won't end up owning us.
RELEVANT POST:
Psychological Risk Management
.
Thinking in Themes


When we think of trading "themes" in the markets, we naturally think of portfolio managers and longer-term investors: those who trade fundamentals and relationships among asset classes. But there is much to be said for theme-based thinking among shorter-term market participants as well.
In my recent post, I emphasized the importance of confirmations between movements of an index (such as the S&P 500 Index futures, above) and the movements of component sectors (such as the S&P 500 Index financial stocks, XLF, below). As you can see from the charts, the financial stocks (like the consumer staples, healthcare, and utilities sectors) did not confirm the 13:00 PM CT low in the ES contract. That led to a sharp reversal shortly thereafter, as selling pressure could not sustain a broad market decline.
But there's another way of thinking about this pattern. We know from the news (and my recent Twitter posts) that weakness among financial issues has been a major market theme. When sellers have aggressively pushed these stocks lower, the broad market has generally followed. In that sense, the financial stocks have been an excellent barometer for stock market sentiment, especially around risk-assumption and risk-aversion.
When we have a low in the broad index that is *not* confirmed by a bellwether sector, the market is telling us that--at least in the short run--the market theme is not operative. Despite the price lows in ES, there is some relative risk appetite among the weakest stocks, the most vulnerable sector. This is very important market information.
Knowing the market bellwethers at any given time and tracking their performance vis a vis the broad averages is a kind of thematic thinking that can lead to excellent intraday trade ideas. For the trader looking at the ES contract only, the afternoon rally came out of the blue. The thematic trader, however, saw the divergence and was not surprised by the reversal.
RELEVANT POST:
Trading by Intermarket Themes
.
Tuesday, March 04, 2008
Tuesday Ramblings From Brett
I've spent the last two hours answering emails from readers and traders. Amazing how much is going on. Having come back from visits to trading firms in the UK recently, on the docket the next few weeks are trips to meet with traders in Chicago, NY, CT, FL, and MA. What that tells you is that current market conditions are challenging even for experienced, professional traders. With volatility up, correlations among markets high, and plenty of violent countertrend moves, it's a time to preserve capital as well as pursue opportunity. I met with quite a few traders today in Chicago, and the best ones are picking their spots and being patient. When there's good movement in markets, you don't have to press to make things happen.
I also had an excellent meeting with my editor at Wiley, and it looks as though we have a very early January, 2009 publication date for my new book. This one will be a very practical guide for traders that outlines literally hundreds of exercises and techniques that traders can use to help themselves with both the psychological and performance aspects of trading. Many thanks to those who expressed interest in contributing to the new book. Incorporating ideas and techniques from others will make the book far more well-rounded than if I were the only one sharing resources.
Here's an idea that I'd like some feedback on in the comments section, if you're so moved: Remember the "Trading Coach Project" I did with "Trader C", in which I provided over a month of free coaching in return for the right to post our work on the blog? I'm thinking of extending the project to an entire trading firm. I would work for a month or so with the traders at the firm free of charge, and they--in return--would allow me to share information about the coaching with readers. It would be a rare look inside a professional trading firm: what they do, how they do it, and how they work on themselves. Any thoughts?
As always, thanks for the interest; it's much appreciated--
Brett
Training for Traders at Proprietary Trading Firms
First let's review terminology: A proprietary trading group is a group of traders that trades the capital of the firm. The firm puts up the trading capital and provides risk management, computer (IT) support, office space, and brokerage arrangements. This is in contrast with a trading arcade, which provides office space, computer support, and brokerage, but does not provide trading capital. It is a group environment for trading your own money.
A proprietary group typically generates its income from a split of trading profits, as well as by charging fees for overhead ("desk fees") and commissions. An arcade often acts as broker and makes its money from fees and commissions, but--because the trader is trading his/her own capital--does not typically take a large share of trading profits.
As a rule, firms that generate more of their own income from a split of trading profits have a greater vested interest in providing traders with ongoing training. After all, if the traders succeed, they succeed as a firm. When a firm is making most of their money from commissions, they'll generate income whether traders are profitable or not. They have less of an incentive to provide ongoing training.
Most prop firms and arcades are small operations when compared with investment banks and hedge funds. Rarely can they afford full-time staff dedicated to training. This is not necessarily out of a lack of interest in training; it's a simple economic reality. New traders trade small, and even with training, a high percentage of new traders do not succeed in the long run. It is very challenging to make a dedicated training program pay for itself.
As a result, much training at prop firms is either informal--the result of connecting with a senior trader and obtaining advice and mentoring--or is limited to several-week courses that precede live trading. Of course, it's too much to expect that a several week course could lead one to trading proficiency. Mostly the courses teach traders the basics, such as how to use the trading platform, how to manage risk, etc. It's the follow-up to the course work that is all-important.
So here are a few things to look for if you're interested in a proprietary trading firm:
* Is there a person (or persons) at the firm who take a dedicated interest in training and actively participate in mentoring new traders?
* Is there an actual training course or program that precedes live trading?
* Is the trading firm invested in training? Do they obtain a significant share of their income from splitting profits with traders?
* Does the trading firm enable you to practice trading in simulation mode prior to going live? Is someone available to provide feedback about simulated trading?
* Does the trading firm demonstrate and explain specific trading methods/setups and provide tools for identifying and trading these?
Here's an example: I'm currently working with a firm (*please* do not ask me for the name; all firms I work with are entitled to anonymity) in which the head traders share their trades with the new traders in real time. This provides valuable ongoing modeling and education. They don't have a formal course, but instead embed training into each trading day. That's the kind of commitment you want to see from a trading firm.
Of course, you'll have to match that commitment with your own. Stated motivation is not enough. I strongly, strongly recommend that traders trade in simulation mode and live (with small size) on their own prior to trying to join any prop firm. There is a great deal you can learn on your own and with online resources (including blogs and live trading rooms) and books. If you can demonstrate a favorable learning curve to a prop firm, you will be someone they want to train. For more advice on joining a prop firm, check out this post.
RELEVANT POST:
How Can I Join a Trading Firm?
.
Monday, March 03, 2008
Using Stock Sector ETFs to Identify Short-Term Market Reversals
As you can see from the chart of the ES futures above, the market made a marginal low for the day at the second blue arrow before retracing much of the day's range. My research finds that, when stock indexes make relative highs or lows that are not confirmed by a significant number of the index components, the odds of reversal are greatly enhanced.With the ES, an easy way to check on the behavior of index components is to track the S&P 500 sector ETFs, most of which are quite actively traded. The new lows in the afternoon in ES were confirmed by new lows in the energy sector (XLE); technology sector (XLK); and a very marginal new low in the materials sector (XLB). The new lows were not confirmed by the important financial sector (XLF); industrials (XLI); consumer discretionary sector (XLY); consumer staples (XLP) ; or (narrowly) healthcare (XLV).
In general, when half or more of sectors or stocks are not confirming a move, that's when you want to be on the lookout for reversal. In practice that means that short-term traders need to be watching more than the cap-weighted index they're trading, as a few highly weighted stocks can paint a misleading price picture on the screen.
RELEVANT POSTS:
Using Intraday New Highs/Lows to Gauge Market Trends
What We Can Learn From New Highs/Lows
.
A Daytrading Pattern With the NYSE TICK

As long-time readers know, one of the market indications I follow is the distribution of the NYSE TICK as that unfolds during the day. This morning provided a particularly good illustration of a short-term pattern that I find especially useful: a series of rising bottoms in the TICK, suggesting that selling pressure is drying up over time. Once we see price moving to relative highs from one TICK peak to the next, those successive drops in the TICK become nice entry points on the long side. The price lows at recent TICK bottoms also provide a natural stop loss point for the quick daytrade.
.
Following the Financial Stocks

The banks continue to underperform, and GS has moved to a new low this AM. If institutional investors don't have confidence in the financial system and are aggressively selling these shares, it's difficult to imagine sustaining a bull move in stocks. Indeed, short-term traders have done well by playing off relative strength and weakness in the financial sector, as these stocks are capturing the hopes and fears of large market participants.
.
Indicator Update for March 3rd



In my last indicator update, I concluded that, "All in all, the evidence is suggesting an absence of bullish interest, as observed in the NYSE TICK, the weak new highs/lows, weak momentum, and tepid AD Lines." This past week, not much has changed that assessment.
* New Highs/Lows - We can see from the top chart that new 20 day lows vs. highs have continued to expand, with 395 NYSE, NASDAQ, and ASE stocks making fresh highs and 1665 making new lows. As long as new lows are expanding, it is premature to be bottom-fishing for anything other than a short-term trade. At a wider time frame, we had 15 NYSE common stocks register fresh 52-week highs on Friday, against 99 new lows. The latter is the highest number of new lows since the January bottom. Among S&P 500 stocks, we had no annual highs on Friday against 26 new lows; among S&P 600 small cap issues, we had 2 new 52-week highs and 37 new lows. All in all, we're seeing a deterioration of strength, though new lows are well off their very expanded levels from late January.
* Cumulative Adjusted TICK Line - Note from the second chart above how the recent market bounce was not at all confirmed by our Cumulative Adjusted TICK Line, suggesting that bullish participation was waning. Since then, we've broken to new lows in the Line, confirming what we're seeing among the new highs/lows. We need to see bullish sentiment sustained before we can put in a durable market bottom. The TICK Line bounce from the January lows was impressive, but has since faded. My readings from Thursday and Friday suggest both an absence of buyers (low positive TICK readings) and an excess of selling pressure (extreme negative TICK readings).
* Overbought/Oversold - The bottom chart tracks the cumulative line for my Demand/Supply Indicator, which has been a very good overbought/oversold measure of late. We see deterioration in the cumulative line in keeping with the new highs/lows and TICK, as we've entered oversold territory. Note that readings below -30 have typified recent market lows on a short-to-intermediate term basis; we're currently around -10.
* Advance/Decline Lines - The AD Line for NYSE common stocks remains above its January lows, though not by much. The same is true for the AD Line specific to S&P 500 and NASDAQ 100 stocks, but we're seeing marginal new lows in the AD Line for the S&P 600 small caps and the broad NASDAQ Composite. This is telling us that small caps have resumed weakness relative to large caps. All of these lines are in downtrends longer-term.
* Momentum - Among S&P 500 stocks, we're seeing 24% trading above their 50-day moving averages, a significant deterioration from the 55% at the recent market peak. Similarly, we're seeing 29% of S&P 600 small cap stocks trading above their 50-day MAs, down from 51% recently. My Demand/Supply measure of short-term momentum was very weak on Friday, with Demand at 24 and Supply at 228. It is not at all unusual for momentum to hit extremes before we see actual price highs or lows for a market move.
All in all, we continue to see deterioration in the indicators and a possible test of the January lows in the making. I am not inclined to buy this market until we see definitive evidence of greater buying interest, momentum, and strength.
.
Sunday, March 02, 2008
Cross-Talk: The Challenge of Hiring Successful Traders
A number of trading firms that work with me begin by asking my help for their traders, but then expand the scope of our collaboration to aid with the hiring process itself. The simple economic reality is that it is much cheaper to hire the right people than to hire struggling traders who require extensive support and risk management.
Hiring successful traders is more of a challenge than one might think. Partly this is because we don't have a great deal of research to draw upon to predict trading success from failure. Often, trading firms make the (flawed) assumption that success is a function of personality traits, leading them to seek people with the "right" interests and characteristics. Even a cursory overview of successful traders at any firm, however, reveals considerable diversity in personality features.
My personal experience across trading firms is that there is no holy grail of right traits that generate success, but the presence of certain characteristics can almost certainly ensure failure. Across dozens of trading firms, I don't think I've ever encountered a successful trader who displayed a high degree of neuroticism (tendency toward negative emotion) and a low degree of traits related to risk-taking.
A different approach to hiring successful traders is to focus on expertise, rather than personality. That is, we look for talents and skills that are predictive of success for particular kinds of trading. An interesting article identifies five facets of expertise:
* Experts rely on experience to guide them, rather than explicit rules;
* Experts perform tasks automatically, rather than through (self-) conscious effort;
* Experts display significant efficiencies in processing information;
* Experts possess multiple strategies for dealing with challenging situations;
* Experts approach problems more flexibly than beginners, relying more heavily upon intuition.
As I indicate in an article from a few years back, much of expertise is the result of implicit learning. The expert trader is one who has experienced so many markets and market patterns that their response to these (and anticipation of these) becomes second nature. If a trader has career promise, he or she should show evidence of a learning curve that is consistent with expertise development. Instead of screening prospective traders for personality alone, trading firms should "get under the hood" and investigate a trader's actual trading statements and knowledge base for signs of growth and development.
The research I summarized in my book on performance is unequivocal: Those who develop expertise are immersed in their work--and in working on themselves as performers. There is a qualitative difference between the learning of the competent performer and the learning of the expert, and the difference can be traced to the nature and degree of the developing expert's immersion in his or her craft.
We tend to make decisions based upon the information that is most readily available. Casual impressions from interviews and simple personality observations thus dominate the hiring landscape. To delve deeper into developing expertise takes a kind of expertise itself, which perhaps is the reason even very sophisticated trading organizations rely on relatively primitive hiring practices.
RELEVANT POST:
A Look at a World-Class Trader
.
Abandoning the U.S. Dollar: A Look at World Interest Rates
So it is in the world money markets. Take a look at government interest rates around the world as of Friday:
THREE MONTH (TWO YEAR) RATES:
U.S. - 1.84% (1.62%)
U.K. - 5.2% (4.07%)
Japan - .57% (.56%)
Germany - 3.96% (3.16%)
Brazil - 11.8% (12.46%)
Australia - (6.72%)
So we have six banks, called U.S., U.K., Japan, Germany, Brazil, and Australia. In a relatively short period of time, the U.S. bank has cut its interest rates to dollar holders to become more like Japan than Europe or Brazil. From that perspective, it's not surprising that dollar holders have fled the currency in favor of the alternatives. After all, why not sell low-yielding dollars in favor of higher yielding currencies and invest in resource-rich areas such as Brazil and Australia--particularly when the management of the U.S. bank is signaling even lower rates ahead?
RELATED POST:
Identifying Market Themes
.
Musical Interlude #2
* VNV Nation - Illusion: "The world is just illusion, trying to change you." (Doll Face video from Andy Huang).
* Assemblage 23 - Drive: "Sometimes I drive to run from all my demons."
* Cruxshadows - Birthday: "So look at your life: who do you want to be before you die...you haven't got forever."
* The Arcade Fire - No Cars Go: "Between the click of the light and the start of the dream."
* London After Midnight - Sacrifice: "Darkness...it's all I want to see."
* Eisbrecher - Ohne Dich: "What is the sun without your light?"
* Morrissey - I Have Forgiven Jesus: "I carried my heart in my hands, do you understand?"
.
Saturday, March 01, 2008
UltraShort ETFs as a Sentiment Gauge
Because QID (and its S&P 500 Index equivalent, SDS) expresses an aggressive bearish opinion on the market, it might be ideally suited to serve as a sentiment gauge. A look at the trade data finds that at recent market bottoms, such as March, 2007; August, 2007; and January, 2008, daily QID volume has expanded to twice or more of its average trading volume. That is, traders seem to become most aggressively bearish just as markets are making an intermediate-term low.
It's in that vein that I note, with Friday's stiff decline, that trading volume in QID did not show any expansion. Indeed, it was slightly below its 20-day moving average. It's when the ultra bears become ultra bearish that I will be most likely to look for a meaningful market bottom.
RELEVANT POSTS:
NASDAQ Volume and Sentiment
Sentiment and the Last Hour of Trading
.
Identifying Market Themes From ETF Performance and Volume
When we look at ETF performance and volume, we can gain some insight into hot market themes. Not surprisingly, ETF daily volume is dominated by the SPY and QQQQ instruments for the S&P 500 Index and NASDAQ 100 Index, respectively. After that, it gets interesting. The third most popular ETF as of Thursday's trade was the S&P 500 Index financial stock sector ETF, XLF. It is down over 11% over the past month, compared to SPY, which is only down 2.58% over that same period. The high volume decline suggests widespread pessimism about this sector, despite Fed (and sovereign wealth fund) attempts at relief.
Fourth and sixth in volume are the UltraShort vehicles for the QQQQ (QID) and SPY (SDS). These enable traders to take double-size short positions on the indexes, and thus are instruments favored by very bearish participants. Since the start of 2007, 20-day volume in QID, for example, has expanded over 10 times. Once again this speaks to the pessimism of market participants--and their desire for leverage, a theme I'll be touching upon in my next post.
Significantly, we have ETFs representing market indexes from Japan (EWJ), Emerging Markets (EEM), Brazil (EWZ), EAFE (EFA), and Taiwan (EWT), and Hong Kong (EWH) in the top 20 volume list--a strong indication of the degree to which investors and traders are taking a global perspective on markets and diversifying beyond the U.S. It is interesting to see the Brazil ETF at #9 in volume, given that it is up over 9% in the past month--a clear outperformer relative to U.S., Asian, and European bourses.
Finally, also within the top 20 ETFs for volume are instruments for S&P 500 energy stocks (XLE), S&P 500 materials stocks (XLB), and gold (GLD). This is a clear reflection of the flow of money into commodities and commodity-related issues. All three are up on a one-month basis, a notable contrast to the broad indexes, which are all lower over that period.
The above, of course, is a static view of volume and performance. It is the flow of funds in and out of ETFs that help us identify sectors and themes gaining favor. By tracking these statistics over time, we can follow in the footsteps of institutional investors and ride important market trends.
RELEVANT POST:
Tracking the Stock Market's Largest Traders
.
